Does anyone pull a hybrid with a minivan?

Discussion in 'PopOut (Hybrids)' started by Mrs_P, Feb 14, 2010.

  1. Mrs_P

    Mrs_P Claremore, OK

    251
    0
    Jan 19, 2009
    Claremore, OK
    I have a 2005 Pontiac Montana V6. I pull a 10ft box popup Jayco right now. I am looking at getting a hybrid with the ends popping out for sleep. With the towing packing I can pull 3500. I am interested in the Jayco Export 17C and The Surveyor SV180T. Any other recommendations?

    Thanks in advance,
     
  2. hvac1877

    hvac1877 Old Dominion Iron Chefs Highland Springs, Va

    2,828
    14
    Mar 10, 2008
    Highland Springs Va
    once you hook up to the hybrid and 2 people in the van you be at your max limit!!!!! You will need a TV that can tow at least 5500lbs!!!! That will be a 80% max towing limit. the camper dry weight is 2935 with max cargo 565 lbs total of 3500 at the max for the van that is not including the people in the van
     
  3. pixel

    pixel Campers: Nature's way of feeding mosquitoes. Unkn.

    450
    0
    May 4, 2008
    Massachusetts
    I would not do it.

    Please remember that it is not simply how much you "can" pull based on the towing package numbers. There are a lot of other variables to that equation. (what is your vehicle weight rating?/how much tongue weight?/do you have ebrakes?/do you have a WD system?/what can that system handle?/Can your transmission handle the extra load?/Do you have a tranny cooler?/what about your TV brake system without ebrakes?/etc? ) These are just the simple questions. You can not go by the numbers on your hitch.

    My guess is that with people, gear, etc. you are at your limit even with your 10 ft. PUP.

    Please seek professional advice. I am sorry to be blunt, but I would not want to share the road with the proposed TV/Hybrid combination. My advice would be (if you are looking to trade up) is to address your TV needs now and camper needs later. There are lots of deals on better TV's now (trucks/SUV's).

    Sorry,
    Pixel
     
  4. BuxCamper

    BuxCamper Member

    318
    0
    Mar 29, 2003
    Bucks County, PA
    I towed a Coleman Sedona with a Pontiac TranSport equipped with tranny cooler and brake controller. It handled the Sedona at about a ton fine. However, I would not have considered my current Niagara which is closer to 3000 pounds with the TranSport . I would just be to close to the limits. GM's Venture, TranSport and siblings are excellent vehicles and capable tow vehicles up to their limits but still are front wheel drive unibody vehicles. Having a vehicle with a full frame gives you a lot more capability.
     
  5. fallsrider

    fallsrider Active Member

    1,777
    2
    Nov 16, 2006
    NC
    I wouldn't do it, either. For a brief time, DW and I considered a HTT. But when I ran the numbers, it became apparent to me that I wouldn't be happy towing one, and the large wind drag from a full size TT or HTT would really tax the Sienna's engine and transmission. We opted not to change anything until we could someday afford a more capable TV and a HTT.

    On our week-long summer trip to the mountains last year, we were coming down a 5-mile-long grade that's about 7%. We met another Sienna climbing the other side pulling probably a 16' or 17' TT. I remember thinking how hard that Sienna's drive train must be working to get up that hill. We climbed it 4 days before maintaining 55 to 60 mph. The other Sienna probably wasn't maintaining 40.

    If you only ever tow on flat ground, you could get by with it, but you would still be over on the numbers. I think Jayco (and I'm a fan of their products) and other manufacturers that market 3,500 GVWR TTs to their customers as towable by minivans are doing them a huge disservice. It's dishonest at the least.
     
  6. Luv2ridebikes

    Luv2ridebikes New Member

    1,949
    0
    Apr 17, 2005
    Granger, IN
    Minivans are marginal towing platforms, but pop ups were created with that in mind. IMHO - the responses are dead on. Even on level roads, the first semi blowing by you and you will learn what it feels like when the tail wags the dog. Upgrade to a much sturdier tow vehicle first!
     
  7. ALICAM

    ALICAM New Member

    307
    0
    May 10, 2007
    Southwestern Ontario
    and yet on the other hand I tow my Rockwood Roo 19 with my 2003 Windstar without any problems
     
  8. aerohead34

    aerohead34 New Member

    26
    0
    Apr 10, 2007
    Athens
    We had a 2004 Pontiac Minivan extended length that we pulled our starcraft 1701L popup. The 1701L doesnt have brakes. It didnt have the factory tow package. On level ground it did ok, but We got into two situations that scared the beetlejuice out of us. We had a tractor trailer pull out in front of us on a little two lane road. We had to slam on breaks and I did not believe we would stop. We missed the truck by inches. A short time later we were traveling thru Chattanooga when it was raining cats and dogs and the traffic was stopped ahead of us. I could feel the little pop up pushing us down the mountain. We came so close to sliding and the popup jack knifeing that I dont like thinking about it. We decided to get something bigger; a used full sized E150 van. It has the 4.6L V8 and pulls just fine. It has a 6600 towing limit, but I am not sure I would want to pull more than 4500 lbs with it. I have heard people talk of a 80% rule that you dont want to pull more than 80% of the max allowable. Our Montana always felt too light and too weak to pull even our little popup. I feel much safer in the E150 and still get 18-19 mpg which was what I was getting with the Montana.
     
  9. bflentje

    bflentje Member

    317
    7
    Aug 24, 2009
    I do not think my Olds would pull my Jayco 1206 effectively let alone something larger.
     
  10. peaceman

    peaceman New Member

    39
    0
    Feb 13, 2010
    Having some personal experience with this I would not do it. I had a oldsmobile silhouete that is the same van as yours just a different emblem on the front. The first time I towed my palomino pup behind it the transmission overheated.(my dry weight was close to 2300 lbs) I don't think your tranny can take the strain even though the engine can. My advice is to pick up a tow vehicle that well exceeds your capacity. trust me driving home with only 1st and 2nd gear is not a lot of fun.
    hope this helps.
     
  11. Armitstead2000

    Armitstead2000 New Member

    23
    0
    Jun 26, 2008
    I have a f16 cub. It is on the lighter side of the HTT scale at under 3000 lbs GVWR. I tow it with a Honda Mini. I love it.. As much as I love to camp I couldn't justify upgrading my vehicle for the 6 times a year I go camping. I did get a weight distribution hitch...I am not sure I can really feel the difference but I like the idea of taking the weight off the back and probably better for the tires etc...
     

Share This Page