That is the question. We've only had our NTU pup for a year (as first-time pup owners), and we like it...sort of. But we're thinking of replacing it. Our Jayco has a great floor plan and we have enjoyed it for 20+ days of camping. We had planned to keep the pup for several years, and wouldn't consider replacing it now, except for the rot/water damage (won't go into details, as I already posted about it in the past). Since a DIY job is beyond our time and abilities, DH and I have considered hiring someone (not from a dealership), to replace the floor. However, we know some water also got into the walls and corners (which ended up in the floor) of our pup, which makes us question whether paying someone to repair the floor is even worthwhile, considering the walls are compromised? And while we think we fixed many of the leak sources, we're not 100% sure. With that thought in mind, we've also been considering replacement options. We really don't want to shell out the $$ to buy new, but also don't want to waste it on another leaky/damaged pup. Despite some of the recent rants on the Portal, we are interested in the new Somersets, because the walls and roof are free of wood. And, the floor is Performax 500, which is supposed to be more dimensionally stable and water resistant than plywood, and by the same token, better than OSB. I can't help but think that this could result in a longer-lasting pup than some others out there. While a 2013 Somerset Utah can be had for around $13,000 at our nearest CN dealership, I've seen two beautiful Coleman Utah's on Craig's List for $5,000 or less. But, they have the wonderful/hated front storage compartments that often leak. And possibly the ABS roof. We can't figure out whether to: 1) Pay someone to fix what we have and hope the walls stay structurally sound for a while; 2) Buy used and hope it lasts; or 3) Buy new (most likely a Somerset), in hopes that it will be the rot-proof pup of our dreams? FWIW - QuickSilvers are out. I want a "roof" on the pup. What would you all do? I know everyone's answers will vary, but I would love some opinions. I'm sick of worrying about the pup every time we use it! Thanks in advance, to all of you smart campers!