Ive got a peculiar situation, but Ill try to be short. I'm a first time buyer with a family of four ( 5yo and 8mo kids). We will mostly be weekend campers. I would like to keep the pup for a as long as possible, so it needs growing room. I have a peculiar situation with a 5th wheel trade in that was given to us by my in laws to get a pop up. The NADA values for the campers are accurate, and the pups are in tip-top shape. They have different extras, but are equally like new. Which option would you choose? Option #1 2011 Jayco Jay Series 1006 ($8500 NADA value) from a dealer for an even swap with the 5th wheel. Its a little smaller than you THINK you would like, but love the front cargo box. Option #2 2011 Coleman Sun Valley ($10,000 NADA value) bigger size, LOVE the outdoor shower and kitchen "bump out", but will have to pay $1500 out of pocket. You have the money easily available.